Meeting Overview

The Berkeley City Council convened a special meeting on July 23, 2025, led by Mayor Adena Ishii, with most council members present except Ben Bartlett and Shoshana O'Keefe. The meeting addressed several significant issues, including an appeal against a landmark designation and a service change by AC Transit. Public comments, particularly from AC Transit representative Ryan Lau, highlighted the upcoming service realignment in response to post-pandemic changes in ridership patterns. The meeting primarily focused on the appeal concerning the landmark designation of properties at 2421 and 2425 Durant Avenue, as well as the implications of state housing laws on local development projects.

Main Agenda Items

• AC Transit Service Change: Ryan Lau from AC Transit announced a service realignment effective August 10th, aimed at maintaining reliability and equity within budget constraints. This change responds to shifts in ridership due to hybrid and remote work.

• Landmark Designation Appeal: The council examined an appeal against the Landmarks Preservation Commission's (LPC) decision to designate 2425 Durant Avenue as a landmark. The appeal, presented by Robert Rivera from the Land Use Planning Division, argued that the designation violated SB 330 and the Housing Accountability Act, which protect housing projects from new standards post-application. The Berkeley Architectural Heritage Association (BAHA) advocated for maintaining the designation due to the property's historical significance.

• Development Project at Shattuck Avenue and Derby Street: The council discussed a proposed mixed-use development project, which involves demolishing an existing building to construct a new residential structure. Key issues included parking requirements, the placement of the driveway, and the impact on neighborhood safety and traffic.

Decisions Made

• Landmark Designation Appeal: The council voted to uphold the appeal, reversing the LPC's landmark designation for 2425 Durant Avenue. This decision was based on legal constraints under state law, emphasizing the need to align local policies with housing development goals. Council members highlighted the importance of a proactive approach to historic preservation, including a comprehensive historic context statement.

• Development Project Approval: The council addressed an appeal against the Zoning Adjustment Board's (ZAB) decision to approve a mixed-use development at Shattuck Avenue and Derby Street. Despite public concerns about safety and traffic, the council affirmed the ZAB's decision, constrained by state laws limiting alterations to the project. The council acknowledged the project's potential economic benefits and the inclusion of very low-income units.

Overall, the meeting underscored the tension between historic preservation and housing development, navigating the interplay between local priorities and state mandates. The council demonstrated a commitment to balancing these interests while adhering to legal frameworks, highlighting the complexities of urban planning in Berkeley.